Citizenship (Amendment) Bill: Dividing India Again? | Ep.91 #TheDeshBhakt with Akash Banerjee
Articles,  Blog

Citizenship (Amendment) Bill: Dividing India Again? | Ep.91 #TheDeshBhakt with Akash Banerjee


Imagine this little lego house as our country. Like this house, our country is also made of different colors(sects) of people. These colors are the building blocks of our nation. Now suddenly, if someone starts to segregate these colors, this house will be demolished. Our country is like this only, comprising different colors. Now if you’ll try to separate certain colors from others, our country would be divided. This is what Citizenship (Amendment) Bill is trying to do to us. BJP is back in power and without any obstruction this time, it would be able to focus on its dream projects. Like, 100% literacy, better GDP, free press. BJP has one more ambitious project. “Temple will be built there for sure.” Not this, this term’s plan is…, “We will work for a Hindu nation” HINDU NATION. To fulfill its dream, BJP has passed the Citizenship (Amendment) Bill in Lok Sabha on Jan 8, 2019. According to which, all Hindus, Sikhs, Jains, Parsis, and Christians from Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Bangladesh can apply for Indian citizenship. But there is no such clause for Muslim and Jewish immigrants. Many objections were raised on this bill. The big question is whether this bill, which gives special privileges to certain sects , is against our secular constitution? Internationally too, citizenship is not granted on the basis of religion or caste but on your ability and need. Millions of people who migrate from India are not asked their religion but what they can do for their new country. In the last five years, our nation has seen many new threats. For eg., Libtards, Tukde-Tukde gang, Khan Market and TV debates. But all these “so-called” protectors were also afraid of something, not elections though. Why would you fear elections when Election Commission is so friendly, Amit Shah is your strategist and Ambani is your supporter?! They were afraid because Hindus are in danger. They are not wrong, Hindus are in danger. Not only Hindus but Jains, Sikhs, Parsis, Christians, all are in danger; not in India though, in our neighboring countries. BJP answers their enemies in the same language only, tit for tat. So like Jinnah divided the country on the basis of religion, BJP would now grant citizenship on the basis of religion. Hence the persecuted minorities of Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Bangladesh can now apply for Indian citizenship. But it is not so for the persecuted Muslim minorities from the same countries. Well, we do have enough oppressed Muslims in our own country, that we do not need more! And anyway, “For the Muslims, their motherland is Pakistan.” There is nothing to be surprised about this bill. When they were shouting, “GO TO PAKISTAN”, we must have understood that they are framing it wrong; when they actually meant “COME TO INDIA”. Clauses in this bill are more biased than nepotism. Where the Citizenship Act, 1955 asks for a continuous stay in the country for 11 years; this amendment would reduce this duration for 6 years for non-muslims sects only. Also, any case pending against those mentioned in the bill regarding their citizenship shall be abated. Basically, the law has to change for certain people only. Let’s agree for a second that BJP had honest intentions behind this bill, “You kidding?!” But the population of Bangladeshi Hindus has increased from 1.4 crores to 1.7 crores in 2017; Do we even have enough resources to accommodate these many people? Certainly! Our exclusive health and education infrastructure can possibly provide for entire Bangladesh’s population! Apart from CAB 2019, NRC is another major crisis on citizenship, northeast India is facing right now. “Northeast? Where is it exactly?!” “NRC, National Citizens…..Register of….Citizens.” Now if the leaders who are monitoring NRC are so confused; what might’ve happened to those 40 lakh people who were declared foreigners under it?! Now, these were not any objects, they are real people and these people had to prove their nationality. You might be wondering how difficult can that be?! It’s not an easy task, These 40 Lakh people had to provide written documents that they came to India before March 25, 1971, as mentioned in Assam Accord. Although the process is being governed by the Supreme Court itself, a lot of mishaps are noticed. People of Assam have protested for years for NRC to be updated; and though the Supreme Court has ordered for the update, BJP has taken credit for it unabashedly. Today, the Assamese are again protesting against Citizenship (Amendment ) Bill which the BJP brought. This bill would safeguard about 20 lakh Bengali Hindus from any proceedings under NRC Terms and conditions: Keep voting for BJP. Both these issues have many complexities but the government has been diverting any questions; “Soldiers are fighting for us, we can at least face some troubles.” But what if the soldier is being troubled himself?! Many army personnel like Kargil war veteran, Md. Sanaullah, have to prove their citizenship today. How funny is it that we celebrate an actor who played a soldier on screen as a patriot ,but an actual soldier who fought for the country is not given any help from even the army! After 30 years of service, a former lieutenant is sent to the detention camp. What does the army even mean by “Big heart”? Not being able to provide any help to retired army personnel facing questions on his nationality is not “big heart”. Voter ID, service certificates, Presidential certificate were not sufficient for the officials to verify his citizenship. Finally, lawyers like Indira Jaisingh came up and filed a petition in Guwahati High Court and Sanaullah was granted bail. For Bengali Muslims whose names are in the NRC, the struggle isn’t over yet. Any random person can file an objection against you which can lead to further complications. Even the filing of these objections has been very abrupt. On the last date, thousands of objections were filed without any details of the objector, nor with any document supporting the objection. One such case was of a 90-year old man, Ashraf Ali. His name was in the NRC but he got a notice on 23rd May and was called for verification. He took his life on 26th May fearing being sent to the detention camp. These 6 detention camps in Assam are built out of small portions of Assam’s jails only. People in detention camp are not allowed to meet their families, nor do they get any proper legal representation. Forget justice, these poor people don’t even get to present their case. NRC is right now confined to the north-east but it might soon cover the entire country. “Shouldn’t infiltrators be thrown out?!” Sure. Infiltrators should be sent back to their country but should religion be the basis of it? “God has not created us any different? How do you know your religion? Our Constitution makers have also mentioned the word ‘SECULAR’ in the preamble. Our constitution is established on the principle of secularism. Now this bill which gives privileges to a certain religion is now adding to the claim that India is a Hindu nation. Like Pakistan which is officially an Islamic nation. The issue of illegal migrants in Assam is actually a serious one. This was never a religious issue but an ethnic one. NRC too has nothing to do with religion. It treated all foreigners equally. This bill is purely for political gains which treats infiltrators on the basis of religion. Further, the way this bill was being pushed right before the elections is also suspicious. An ordinance is for urgent issues only. Citizenship is a complex issue and the way our government has been pressing it is suspicious. The final question is what is the plan after NRC and CAB? What after all the illegal migrants are identified and sent to detention camps? No country would agree to take them back. Generations of these people have passed in India. Bangladesh has also stated that it won’t take these migrants back so easily. So possibly, this Citizenship (Amendment) Bill is another election scheme only. Presently, the bill has lapsed in Parliament. The question is, what happens now? With Modi coming back to power, this bill is possible to be brought back by BJP. This is what has been claimed by Amit Shah. “BJP government will provide citizenship to Hindu, Sikh, Jain, Parsi, and Christian refugees.” Jinnah gave the two-nation theory in 1940 which partitioned the country into two, Hindustan and Pakistan. The wounds of partition are still not healed. This bill is also based on similar principles which BJP is trying to pass in the Rajya Sabha too. This bill is purely against humanity and promotes religious biases in our country. People have demanded an in-depth researched video on Citizenship (Amendment) Bill. So we tried to understand this bill ourselves and explain it to you. It would be interesting to see what the Supreme Court’s verdict would be over such a controversial bill. Please let us know how you found this attempt to present such complex issues. All the source articles are given in the description, please read. Please like, share, subscribe and comment below. Thanks to our Patreons who support us. You can also support us on Patreon.com, Instamojo, Paypal. All links are given below. You can also visit Kadak Merch to buy the Deshbhakt merchandise. Thanks for watching. Stay connected for more videos.

100 Comments

  • king cobra

    Yeh citizenship ammendment bill, triple talaq etc etc yeh sab jhamela lane se pehle MODI meharbani karke yeh bata de woh jo DEMONETISATION kiya tha uska bade fayda ka khwab dikhaya tha uska kya hua??

  • Sharad Patil

    मेरा पहला शत्रु ऋगवेदी है, दूसरा शत्रु जिहादी है।
    यह सिद्धांत अगर यहां के जाट मराठा रेडी पटेल राजपूत यादव जो यहां के क्षत्रप हैं। यह मान के चलेंगे तो वह खुद और उनका देश भारत बचेगा।

  • Sharad Patil

    कांग्रेस और बीजेपी दोनों ऋग्वेदी पार्टियां है।

  • Sudhanshu Patel

    Hi Bro,
    I am Huge fan of yours work and wish you to grow as it will good for everyone.
    I looked into the the way people can support you. I find patreon that is great but the only problem is it needed credit card.
    other one is paypal , most of common people does't have that account also.
    As of my experience in advertisement and targeting , this system won't be very successful in India.
    If you can share details like `UPI_id` where contributor will not have any condition on amount they wanna contribute or when they wanna contribute will defiantly help you to increase your revenue atleast by double.
    There are few simple but very effective to get funding is use `UPI` or `Paytm` you can also put barcode for payment.
    if you see statical data people feel more safe and confident while paying from these techs over debit or credit cards.
    Not everyone interested or have time to be active member of patreon so it will be great from them to contribute whatever amount they can without any amount boundaries .

  • Irfan Ullah

    I'm from Pakistan and I'm happy that you are pointing out such critical points. And I wish my people also understand our such points.
    Moreover , I like ur videos, good job bro.

  • Shadow Hunter

    Ary hm ko to lgta hy k ya prani India main rhta nhe wrna bjp mhraj k kirpa say is daish drohi ka ram nam satiya kb ka ho jata…
    Respect for truth

  • yashadatta deo

    Well, muslims are not part of the bill because the nations which mentioned in the bill, i.e. Pakistan and Bangladesh are Islamic countries. And for Hindus, Sikhs are other religions, India is the ONLY option. SO yes, it will 100% be excluding Muslims which is correct. And you can argue about the constitution but the constitution is for the people which can be changed as per the constitution, means by the people itself. SO if majority people want that, then it should happen. End off!

  • yashadatta deo

    Besides whoever says still India is a majority hindu country so hindus should not worry are the most ignorant people. Remember from centuries, Current Porkistan and Bangladesh were Hindu regions. Now they are almost 100% muslim regions. SO yes, we HAVE to protect the remaining people.

  • Afgal B

    Bhai jabtak aap jese pyare or achche log he tab tak India💓ke 2tukde koyi nahi Kar sakta😍😍😍😍love you bro

  • saurabh singh

    Anyone from another country of any religion should not be given Indian citizenship. We are already 1.3B people.

  • Champak Nath

    NRC ki baat itni v easy nhi hain. Main assam se hu aur Mere ghar ke pass hi brahmaputra ke nadi dwip main utne bahar k log aa gaye hain jinka kuch naamo nisan tak nhi tha. Aur un sabko nikalne main ye NRC asafl rha.

    Baki abhi assam main Kavi Hindu Majority wale kai jile muslim majority ho gaiye hain.

  • Hassan Roy

    Iraq, Libya and Syria etc where fight between Muslims so this happened to them. But India is in very sensitive condition if Muslim Hindu fight start then India will become like Middle East very soon.

  • Anya Khan

    Apne jinnah k bare me bt to krdi k onho ne muslims k liye alag state manga tha lekin ye nhi btaya k q manga tha waja kya thi ?? Isi liye q k os time hindus majority the orr britian onko support kr rhe the onho ne muslims k khilaf boht propagndas kiye the arya samaj shudhi sangton movements strt kii thi jis me do kam krne the hindus ko ya to muslims ko qatal krna tha ya onka religion bdlna tha partition of benagl howa 1905 me os prrr hindu extremists nikle orr boht muslims ko qatal kr diya dono ka guzara possible tha hi nhi isi liye jinnah ne muslims k liye alag state manga jisme on se koi religion na bdlwa sake onse koi ye na kahe k jaii shrrii ram bolo jai hanoman bolo jese k ajkal india me ho raha he tbrez ansari wala case koi nhi bhola me Allah ka shukr ada krti hn k me pak me peda howi koi non muslim mjhe rule nhi kr raha wrna hmari halt bhi kashmir syria palistine jesi hoti orr kher india k muslims k sth bhi kuch zyada acha nhi ho raha

  • muhammad usman

    Mr jinnah once said, hindustan ky musalmano ko sari zindgi apni loyalty sabit krni pry gi.
    Now after 70 years his prediction got right.

  • Irresistible Libra

    Two Nation Theory Zindabad.
    Thanks to Muhammad Ali Jinnah for a separate and safe country. His words are proving right.

  • M Lukman khan Sudhzae

    Great work brother love u app ka may bhoot bara Fan ho love. u app such bolty ho 😘😘😘😘😘💕🇵🇰Love from pakistan

  • OCCUPIED KASHMIR SRI NAGAR.

    In short INDIAN Muslims become ROHANGIYA, Same Detained center , have to prove petriotism,

    Jinnah was on rite path,

  • Pretty Universe

    In a secular country like india there is no place for religious extremists in politics n parliament. But our country is being run by extremists!

  • Pretty Universe

    Bjp doesn’t want muslims then why are they forcing kashmiris to mingle with india?? Yes in know he wants Kashmir and not kashmiris. We all know why is kashmir lockdown. Well yeah next is genocide and then blame will go to Pakistan…

  • Pretty Universe

    Bjp doesn’t want muslims then why are they forcing kashmiris to mingle with india?? Yes in know he wants Kashmir and not kashmiris. We all know why is kashmir lockdown. Well yeah next is genocide and then blame will go to Pakistan…

  • Pretty Universe

    Bjp doesn’t want muslims then why are they forcing kashmiris to mingle with india?? Yes in know he wants Kashmir and not kashmiris. We all know why is kashmir lockdown. Well yeah next is genocide and then blame will go to Pakistan…

  • Pretty Universe

    Bjp doesn’t want muslims then why are they forcing kashmiris to mingle with india?? Yes in know he wants Kashmir and not kashmiris. We all know why is kashmir lockdown. Well yeah next is genocide and then blame will go to Pakistan…

  • Vasudha Aditya

    Ap ki sari baat sahi hai… Ap ki baato ko jo glt kahe… Unko maa bahan baap bhai… Chacha chahi badhe papa badhi maa dadi sb k trf se… Peeeeeepppp….!!!!

  • DON CARLOS

    Behtreeennn….👍👍
    INDIAA means HINDUU HARAAAMZAAAADDDAAAAAAA……….
    Chalo beta INDIAN-MUSLIM Chuutiyounnn,abb bhi BHONKOOO AUR CHODDOOOO..
    JAI HIND JAI BAHAARAT..
    AUR HUM BOLEENGAY BAHAARAT MAATA RANDII KIII LEYYYYYYY LEYYYYYYY LEYYYYYYY…
    KHULL K LEYYYYYYY KHULL K LEYYYYYYY KHULL K LEYYYYYYY…..!!!!!!!!

  • Noor Nayyar

    Agar Musalmano ko apni citizenship sabit karni paregi toh fir Jinna sahi sabit ho jayega…. BJP desh ko barbaad matt karo…

  • yaseen Qureshi

    Sahi kaha achhe se samjhaya par log dharm k karan samajhna nahi chahte itne logo ko beghar karke desh m khushhali kaise ayegi

  • saurabh majumdar

    এই বিলটা আনতে গেলে ভারতের সংবিধান পাল্টাতে হবে যা খুব বিপদজনক হয়ে উঠতে পারে , এই দেশে বসবাসকারী মুসলমানরা নিজেদের অনিরাপদ মনে করবে আর তাদের পৃথক রাষ্ট্র দাবি করবে যেমনটি ১৯৪৭ এ হয়েছিল !

  • Bhupender Budhwar

    6-7 videos dekhi Teri… 1 m bhi tune bjp k kisi kaam ki tarreef nhi ki… The Desh bhagat ki jga congress bhagat name rakh le apne Chanel ka.. Sale teri har 1 video p Indian se jyada kisi pakistani ka jyada support milta h… Chutiye Itna hi Pyar h Inse to apne ghar pr rakh le na Inko

  • anand pushkar

    Bhai aaj ke political villain NEHRU JI par ek episode banayiye….orr aaj kal jo baate unke baare me khi jaati hai unme kitni sacchhayi hai isko batlayiye pls.

  • Avik Saha

    Hindus or Muslims, if not from India, NOT INDIAN. choices were made in 1947, 1971, bloods were spilled, the people made difficult choice. Citizenship is not ice cream, topping it with both

  • Soumyadeep980

    Yes, we want a Hindu republic country 😀
    And I'm from Bangladesh, a Hindu I want to see muslims suffers just like us :')

  • ankush matta

    Green colour k log intentionally population badha re h uska kya?? 20 crore log konsi minority hoti h itti toh bht si country ki population bhi nahi h..

  • shamsheer naqvi

    God bless u veer ji episode bhot pasand aya wese mujhe aapke sare episodes bhot ache lge 👌👌
    Im waiting for ur upcoming videos plzz jald hi lana 🙏🙏🙏

  • Samir Md

    Jab tak BJP hindu ko khatre me samjhane me safal hai tabhi tak satta me,jaise hi logon ko samajh me Aagaya ke to BJP ka sofra saf ho jaaega

  • Shweta K

    @Akash Banerjee wat u want den from the govt?? To let ppl like zakir nayak to misuse the ryt to speech n brainwash ppl so dat they accept islam?? This is wat u want?? Lagta hai apne apna homework thik se nahi kiya hai u shud knw earlier afgahnistan was a buddhist country..indonesia was hindu now we all knw they r islamic countries… islam me kuch zakir nayik jese log h jo dimaak ki tarah sare religion ko kha re hai!! I personally feel, Not only hinduism bt othr religion r also in danger!! M not against islam..mera dharm har dharm ki repect karna sikhata hai.. i truly repect all religion equally …m jst stating facts n figures….. indian muslims r safer in india only..i belive in our pm. "Sabka sath sabka vikas"..
    aaj govt ki jo bhi scheme h..pakka ghar,farmers ko monetry benifits,health insurance schemes vo hindu muslim sikh sabko equally milti hai! M not a modi bhakt bt i belive in his ideologies (equality,removing poverty ,developmnt etc)

  • Zeeshan Malik

    Allah ka shukar hy Mai Pakistan Mai paida Hua hmry upar koi modi chutya kaqumat ni kra jes ko gussa Aya MA chudwy modi sy apni

  • Rashidul Islam Sayem

    Then people must admit Jinnah was right he was a widespread person for Muslims .. because whatever is happening in India for the name of religion then its pretty obvious he understood and then he tried to save Muslims …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *